{
"status": "PASS_WITH_WORDING_CLARIFICATION",
"scope": "C1132–C1145 independent review of journal, scripts, referenced models and rejected C1138 preparation attempt. No existing files edited; no root research actions executed.",
"first": 1132,
"last": 1145,
"record_bindings": {
"1132": "86bbc080b541650c4f980843e678e6771d29004b41496983831e3ef305bef0b3",
"1133": "8864da50f84957f28dd0b217d4758a05a60155c6269126a2de444e9ec7d449dd",
"1134": "b2790ff9aae211a4d219ef7b6c5d3f8f8810e89e00c883bd0ccc02574e36cbf4",
"1135": "5a2a665e36a8137b9bf2674812de2b4b1f5054f600b737c2e13369b28a788e7f",
"1136": "254450843608614814d7abfc56d2ac74743931bae98a70746a904053f0d2d435",
"1137": "3c8b70efa17b90eb864db0ad36fbe3d9f2df0cf3c60d894a96ad3a268bc6a808",
"1138": "05821410403fa1634cce07779b1bdd92fd33b84002b618f002f1a89a885432f7",
"1139": "2380f5ec86d29a6854949064dffb7d07a6b59091aaa7cdb5ba3ee7bb8ed6b3bf",
"1140": "d44bf2c454695014a0e0010d0429f8faf8b3c9533faddd099a47fe390600e4c6",
"1141": "7ea00029d18b2382ac5c698c75cc2a8abfde668eff8e0c5095d7df061fad15ed",
"1142": "e9b892f41e1032aae886ae8f4f531d760f84364db14ed4785ea813d2e7d627fc",
"1143": "1c1f33cefd0a72109baa242258edbdd5270e953b81cf795d342e13f5ff66af3c",
"1144": "d7b2958392e95807f694515f8f7cb54498944e3a67e9e7b8703b62576c957078",
"1145": "20e5bbe87d8b2ec5c9b0f6dd1eab3f2a9d077d7ae1836e35f804a6c1db0d19de"
},
"script_bindings": [
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1132.py",
"sha256": "30579f9de30f939c1ca9d796a0473360726219b0530886010e541cc033bbda49"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1133.py",
"sha256": "618139d9e7d01d029b78558366eb8bb5f685a228762ee171b7fb0b8a0c64ad4d"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1134.py",
"sha256": "e13668001cf1ab43447061e567cc9386ddae49d1c797606ce07bcefe74b2214d"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1135.py",
"sha256": "7c0ba88d5ddbb48024c06f64f8d72ef377915cd742b65871ac5a5ade0bf5aef0"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1136.py",
"sha256": "d6e6555950f92b15bdb2c953fc3803a18f2c1dd11a6859cab8d986b21be87a43"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1137.py",
"sha256": "44b27255390f5fd497fa40a6323563fe1a209c881f2110b6df882d2e2553e754"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1138.py",
"sha256": "a1405f87549899628a96ff047373620cb86070d310f51053db67b34f80b937be"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1139.py",
"sha256": "71212d72a5f3a7cdbfd843abbe5917666852aab078b53db7b84d1bea8b364e36"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1140.py",
"sha256": "98a2fcb1d283c2ea2dd07cab7bd37bf440025e3f35d2cfbba414edfa7a68f66f"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1141.py",
"sha256": "32a91a1b05a2081d12360b634742d032ccadbd2d47ac6dfe543bd1aa7cc4f328"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1142.py",
"sha256": "702eea53e41646ca9cbf9d287345d5c7a9a37dfc0eeb6de8faba1d05bb88ce60"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1143.py",
"sha256": "b078c23e3445189d0e7d4e4b441cdf36e99bdff019cdb5dba0619953af68fdaf"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1144.py",
"sha256": "94b4c2c9db618cb46d828264aba9e7b861e83d617fb0337a0c58a57e13877bac"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/s1145.py",
"sha256": "285ebf637e929008ac151cbfaad47f76716a4f77bd171fcd68fbf7c6526c8bb6"
}
],
"artifact_bindings": [
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/source_relation_inventory.json",
"sha256": "66f58b98e2c90a3596f86253eb2bc7d5563086f6cc4f844d80343b97a316e1c4",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_age_constraints.json",
"sha256": "a424c44212d21411e61116d36dad64234cf5602e9c4578c3989ac79f8ab308fd",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_age_parametrization.json",
"sha256": "de7e3be7439f8607d97083bb28d39c658f2d44e702d9f70cc9e47c15a0f2128f",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_unresolved_birth_directions.json",
"sha256": "06c8549a24f007d713d04909118201f454eefd03e7b5188a2463cfbf41972610",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_age_cap_inequalities.json",
"sha256": "3bc99eb9d464d5649ce7756d19131a50985dbb4272fa69301647bc5b2bbbee5e",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_early_grid_fibre.json",
"sha256": "fe333c9392687892aa535da1858fa1fb571bf4bb53e83babb93ea0a5c4aa94b6",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_grid_single_measurements.json",
"sha256": "a71a44cba2970798613a05ef054fc169c326a4f021b63764c9a30ec17d4e5e7a",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_age_basis_completion.json",
"sha256": "b4a86d46e1fe491032030e01dbd19b5f4be75570e41dd6ec824d20c3883fe9de",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_age_information_cost.json",
"sha256": "53203ef61c17ad91efec986f1a744f660ce0ee9fefaa08f0b9722ad688850f5e",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/Methuselah_baseline_constraint.json",
"sha256": "3e0ae70dac9acb4008d9ddabe4369fad9fe0a997274246020ac165e5ecee9f9e",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/Methuselah_reduction_decomposition.json",
"sha256": "9613acc437399d19ecf7d394e9e7031aab6d0633eac1ad3bb00846c643bcb5fc",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_capacity_slack_transfer.json",
"sha256": "7f737584f8e0dd53f2a57af2a4fa39e337666e91bbc66594a19bc6f82f4d2e25",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_capacity_step_locations.json",
"sha256": "d66ca2af1e2770ef2b872ecf735a4a81562fedba81a4977961c395fd244f7c70",
"matches_record": true
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/SP_loss_placement_counterexample.json",
"sha256": "761b4d186e53aa9ba06e42fd3cd7c00d5e751ac739537c9ce31c982bbaa7ac73",
"matches_record": true
}
],
"rejected_attempt": {
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/s1138_rejected_uniqueness_attempt.py.txt",
"sha256": "30555bd2840c3348230bfb2e938ce6cecd34c10e1ec79cffd258837a3cf997a8"
},
"source_support": [
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/sources/39-File_51a.Rounded_Scaffold_Mod5_Architecture.md",
"section": "§8.3",
"sha256": "d8aa38afb2a2df8f3bb57937f5d3dea897c286c034a1bee7398938d30e7bd77c",
"exact_matches": {
"65 = ½ × 130": [
973
],
"flanked symmetrically by 65": [
973
]
}
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/sources/29-File_47.Patriarchal_Pairing_Six_Birth_Pairs-1-.md",
"section": "§8.4",
"sha256": "c0a735c82c0109cfefb71459af02fe3184a172d7b8d415ed3a8d143b2122f8f8",
"exact_matches": {
"130 + 105 + 90 + 70 + 65 = 460": [
546
]
}
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/sources/38-File_18.Chronological_Data_Tables-20260919-141048-.md",
"section": "§§2.1.3,3.1,3.1.3,4A.2",
"sha256": "68301ab760bfbe2e874aedc5c8d943ced7a6219d34bc2859332a70713f9630d5",
"exact_matches": {
"187 + 182 + 600 = 969": [
1772
],
"53rd year to primary Noah": [
1455
],
"A cap takes the minimum": [
1538
]
}
}
],
"checks": [
{
"check": "Fourteen sequential reviewed records",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Record hashes valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Rank6 and three free age coordinates",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Source-only three equations have rank3; three cap relations add3",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Recorded kernel is complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Affine parameterization spans the complete solution space",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "All birth-direction coefficients agree",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Fixed and moving birth rows correct",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Affine capacity field exact",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "All recorded boundary witnesses preserve nine lives",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Every integer scale48 through126 has a constructive witness",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Lower and upper boundaries necessary",
"passed": true,
"detail": "Mahalalel capacity847+m>=895 givesm>=48; positive Jared age127−m gives integer m<=126. Seth m<=197.5 and Enoch m>=−355 are redundant."
},
{
"check": "Reduced inequality model matches direct cap including ties",
"passed": true,
"detail": {
"sampled_rational_positive_age_cases": 389,
"symbolic_sufficiency": "The only nonredundant uncapped inequalities are Mahalalel847+m>=895, Kenan847+m+k>=910, Enosh1307−2m−s>=905."
}
},
{
"check": "Lower boundary is a capacity tie, not a fourth strict reduction",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "All ten selected grid/order candidates enumerated exactly",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "All ten grid candidates retain the complete cap output",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Single source-age fibre counts2,3,5",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Any pair of actual interior age values fixes the actual triple",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Failed C1138 uniqueness hypothesis retained and corrected before sealed finish",
"passed": true,
"detail": "The archived assertion would be False. The writer rejects failed checks before journal append. There is one sealed C1138 record, with the corrected result; no claim that the rejection archive alone proves a full external execution log."
},
{
"check": "Three retained ages close rank9 and recover source vector",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Reverse measurements are explicitly counted as inputs",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Methuselah baseline and count-convention decomposition",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Both complete capacity vectors and slack independently recovered",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Positive-part identity yields all nine output reductions",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Located100/120/130 changes regenerate entire capacity-loss field",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Same-total loss exchange changes only Methuselah life by20",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Diagnostic scope and MT counting qualification explicit",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Explicit source support: §8.3",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Explicit source support: §8.4",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Explicit source support: §§2.1.3,3.1,3.1.3,4A.2",
"passed": true
},
{
"check": "Reviewed model artifacts match sealed journal identities",
"passed": true
}
],
"passed_checks": 31,
"failed_checks": 0,
"findings": [
{
"id": "F1",
"severity": "wording_clarification",
"step": 1139,
"blocking": false,
"finding": "The phrase different identification costs is not demonstrated for the actual tuple after C1138 is corrected. With m retained, every single source interior age remains nonunique, and any two recover the tuple in both the unrestricted linear model and the bounded grid.",
"recommended_clarification": "The grid reduces an infinite family to ten candidates; for this source tuple it still requires two retained interior ages, just as the linear model does."
},
{
"id": "F2",
"severity": "terminology_note",
"step": 1137,
"blocking": false,
"finding": "The check name all_admitted_conditions should be read as the selected diagnostic grid/order conditions. The artifact correctly says these are not chronology admissions.",
"recommended_clarification": "Use selected diagnostic conditions in subsequent prose and check labels."
}
],
"scope_assessment": {
"rank": "Six algebraically independent age equations comprise three explicit source relations and three reverse cap measurements with601 held. The cap measurements are not additional independent historical witnesses.",
"inequalities": "m48..126 is the exact integer projection of the stated positive-age/full-output region; ties at m48 do not add a strict clip.",
"grid": "The five-year grid and observed descending order are selected diagnostic restrictions motivated by the source, not a claim that other positive allocations are admitted chronologies.",
"threshold": "The positive-part law is an algebraic consequence of the declared cap; source significance lies in the ordered100/120/130 loss vector and baseline slack, not merely its total350.",
"historical": "No historical MT→SP transmission sequence or statistical rarity is established."
}
}
Evidence
review1132 1145.json
Linked sources and evidence
Edition and provenance
review1132_1145.json
SHA-256 30de0d4a8520297f54b421608127c78308edcef23f329e838836493cccc57bad
C480–C1634/Research_Cycles/C1132_C1431_Recovered/prep/review1132_1145.json