review1232 1252.json

{
  "scope": "Independent review of all21 C1232–C1252 Moses-family steps and the C1252 reader deliverable",
  "status": "PASS_WITH_READER_NOTES",
  "numerical_status": "PASS",
  "created_utc": "2026-09-28T06:04:23.368136+00:00",
  "method": "Source-only path regeneration from the frozen C749 input rows, exact source edits for finite variants, literal23-row source parsing, and an algebraic all-integer proof; no numbered root script executed.",
  "checks": {
    "21_contiguous_records": true,
    "frozen_preparation_unchanged": true,
    "source_and_frozen_input_bindings_unchanged": true,
    "all21_artifact_bindings_match": true,
    "all12_source_excerpts_match_current_literals": true,
    "source_scope_regular_not_lifespan": true,
    "late_source_age_roles_exact": true,
    "late_rounding_preserves480": true,
    "Entry_Moses_tail350_not_Exodus430": true,
    "MT_all25_nodes_rebuilt_from_frozen_rows": true,
    "MT_all24_edges_and_roles": true,
    "MT_heads_and_totals": true,
    "all23_literal_births_both_columns": true,
    "literal_comparison_including_all_shifts": true,
    "five_complete_ordered_blocks": true,
    "all_block_components_retained": true,
    "cycle_2580_2450_1960_family": true,
    "bridge_necessary_not_sufficient": true,
    "source129801_rounded130800_partition": true,
    "complete_postflood_residual_sources": true,
    "fixed_endpoints_and_Reu_shift": true,
    "two_components_not_an_extra930_condition": true,
    "Shem430_follows_same_path_biography": true,
    "4_and2point5_centuries_correctly_located": true,
    "life_amplitudes_invisible_and_SP_scope_preserved": true,
    "all26_nativeLXX_nodes_rebuilt": true,
    "one_native_Cainan_and3960": true,
    "native_LXX_full_partition6601050": true,
    "1380_gap_source_components": true,
    "SP_only_postflood_projection_and_transmitted_head": true,
    "SP_conditional53_52_not_promoted": true,
    "all4_finite_states_rebuilt_by_source_edits": true,
    "initial130490_invariant_allstates": true,
    "specified_cycles_base_only": true,
    "independent_component_switch_supports": true,
    "finite_vs_general930_distinction": true,
    "integer_bridge_base_and_coprimality": true,
    "complete_integer_solution_symbolic_coefficients": true,
    "integer_solution_converse_mod49": true,
    "positive_integer_solutions_k_nonnegative": true,
    "integer_examples_and_no_event_admission": true,
    "reader_numbers_and_SP_source_scope": true,
    "reader_biography_and_typology_distinct": true,
    "reader_correct_narrative_age_owner": true,
    "no_global_uniqueness_historical_statistical_claims": true
  },
  "passed": 45,
  "total": 45,
  "details": {
    "integer_proof": "Divide by10:43m−49n=13. Since43*8−49*7=1, m≡8*13≡6(mod49), so m=6+49k. Substitution givesn=5+43k. Conversely each such pair solves the equation. Both arepositive iff k≥0, giving6/5 as the smallest positive pair. This doesnot select a chronological endpoint.",
    "reader_sha256": "a6cb32355311f08c1084a7069e47dd4e79670b50e4c48107f08837a260f37ff6",
    "artifact_count": 21
  },
  "numerical_corrections_required": [],
  "reader_notes": [
    {
      "type": "reader_clarification",
      "severity": "non-numerical",
      "text": "State the base explicitly near the beginning: Terah70, native CainanOFF, and Shem+2 excluded. These conditions are correct in C1232/model scope but not stated together in the standalone reader draft."
    },
    {
      "type": "reader_wording",
      "severity": "non-numerical",
      "text": "Prefer “ordered Regular chronological path” to “ordered genealogy” in the opening. The complete object includes Joseph→Entry and Entry→Moses event intervals."
    },
    {
      "type": "reader_role_clarity",
      "severity": "non-numerical",
      "text": "Expand the correct shorthand to “Jacob’s age at Joseph’s birth91→90 and Joseph’s age at Entry39→40.” No source owner is numerically reversed in the root artifact."
    }
  ],
  "reviewed_record_hashes": {
    "1232": "7f76461a2706311af841c1c5af4fe570dc63a0dcf90823e622304e427b484b3d",
    "1233": "76f9556e3f9223dfdff315b6ff66077baddc3bfc089ba80cc86f930c394e4b19",
    "1234": "c825c6911a045d7ec949265c7b56d61e5cfac60bf9dded570798bdbfce32c43c",
    "1235": "362bba7b5268b78ee6d944a06e120858dead982a4693cba9ed42ebe1e613e8f8",
    "1236": "1cdacc034d0e9cca51dc49f28996205bde5df1066ecdc8681185f02c19b436d1",
    "1237": "1fd6b282ac7dd6df3e1b48b42b04e4d1d9e505c9e4a5d87046bb01a7a0dfb7aa",
    "1238": "61ae1281aebab090beb8114a89e57ae97942eddbf340ac017a531489bdb73bab",
    "1239": "f0c72be49d98083798a6eb1fec6c9f5a9e9c03f046c76b44d2226bebf86f607b",
    "1240": "59cf6c59ba21b6a932756d544f38cc1af119ab618af6320ccaf63be42d7b1d89",
    "1241": "6fc12af70df07cde20bb9b5f9991896dbeb41bf34a8005194ac52c8d82eafcd2",
    "1242": "720fe5a281df20d78ca69a57d191f3655795ef9a817d7824f9535a3aece62daf",
    "1243": "47f7e3b59dd6cde9fa1c0b31e0b437eaacd1250fac83329e3836ea15e0ed26c9",
    "1244": "e8b4474dc6801fe86e85af21aeb387d4d985f8679c2a0d75ce1460b80e09c67e",
    "1245": "0e080899f4cc4a0bf0c2e39ba9f8b31d991efa901ba260655f9b5f1f01d22277",
    "1246": "6059f65b69562549b75606fda1673f4bd612f39f0b80bbb0a6f58cc02d30aa5d",
    "1247": "1bb01778a9d42290152bbcf2bc521b80eb3952d11162e326b9e0ba9abfe0cdb9",
    "1248": "979f4e434f1c211f30126c14fe0df71267ab61de92ad5d034c0351923d58ad8d",
    "1249": "e1cb6415ea15fd391ab1252f93896d91d671344b5e92e61b4f55c8c853538925",
    "1250": "0677fb515a567213d1cedea44caa1354604c9c1a595221eb22190378fe30c3e2",
    "1251": "7c0058c4e02b3e478122547a2c0b1b97a879fe69f4aecc5fb22c9edba5e1d094",
    "1252": "172c30a9ad055465f732eb24cb2d55c10d1196a606af2641ba362816cce863dc"
  },
  "bound_artifacts": [
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_family_source_scope.json",
      "sha256": "06a5bba4785e5618166ca37a2d8af33481b69bffbe2ec5d55896822d63defe0f",
      "bytes": 33769
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_late_path.json",
      "sha256": "5388360af0150b9b39529cc6c4be9c594b16117ae94a2405c94581d7d1f62f64",
      "bytes": 606
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_MT_complete_path.json",
      "sha256": "2fe1381ccaccd97ad19616296b7c616507d4de1e0d87a7ee6de89b110edc3ec1",
      "bytes": 3929
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_MT_literal_comparison.json",
      "sha256": "8b1248523155d5fb20d383d2697c41527128d04648320d88b9071cc3dbff10eb",
      "bytes": 4164
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_five_source_blocks.json",
      "sha256": "a91b4f03fd5a396f77ecfb589276deb60f91456b851a48563addce0a32e7de1f",
      "bytes": 1522
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_cycle_family.json",
      "sha256": "383622af80e02a860a556b78cab0e461136ba9ff53e4266e2f32899288d61ab4",
      "bytes": 479
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_bridge_dependency.json",
      "sha256": "38c25a7954001979fe0b8819837abdf7f7f785548833206462452b50c89e59cc",
      "bytes": 691
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_postflood_partition_residuals.json",
      "sha256": "ea4867aadb57486cb8c9f9d0698491cbf2304a0e6b644b303da9a4567b7af00b",
      "bytes": 1346
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_postflood_fixed_endpoints.json",
      "sha256": "d1c9d0ef76ad9721054add0426b26bf4fe4500b7d9bffd2692f6a55a97e47b5d",
      "bytes": 528
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_Adam_component_correspondence.json",
      "sha256": "c79ab436f165036017e2c7f77d5017c2a82d50a0982296779e4044d40aed81a6",
      "bytes": 607
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_Shem_death_consequence.json",
      "sha256": "9c68522f696c11245f897bffd9a7b2503f518c5873fed9b2660cf7fa13664d83",
      "bytes": 269
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_partition_amplitude_transfer.json",
      "sha256": "f950758b3fe2b42cd1af704145c84729b4233647d44bfe4fc1ba8a7c1fc99eb1",
      "bytes": 603
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_LXX_native_complete_path.json",
      "sha256": "349e15040eb75bcb325bb2c83865a847266e0b60a265da53410dc040515fd403",
      "bytes": 3839
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_MT_LXX_gap_provenance.json",
      "sha256": "9477a963ed28fe8d44beedfde45d79929feaf8d97455b7f56fc044270a7121e8",
      "bytes": 431
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_SP_source_scope.json",
      "sha256": "bb0226d26198bf20f123ba0f7b3376d4119b88230b85a8ad3803b14288a8d261",
      "bytes": 540
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_finite_MT_states.json",
      "sha256": "2a986f97684f64c2d215b4ec84753f988bda2ed6fb26c762e66cadf2c8149608",
      "bytes": 1333
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_finite_relation_survival.json",
      "sha256": "e59d1304eb3a8f17875607d3c1e40f42b2218ef6f2aef034f3c68e5c17d97488",
      "bytes": 1181
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_total_vs_components.json",
      "sha256": "3954330c4e0ce81c119acb258672c86b4fca5c41c1c9b04e7bcdd495b71c8a73",
      "bytes": 624
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_cycle_bridge_integer_family.json",
      "sha256": "5511afbe3ed58ac79ffe1d94b93293f8fab73e811d91fa86e0454fffd7af8275",
      "bytes": 587
    },
    {
      "path": "model/Moses_family_source_cost.json",
      "sha256": "5d7d618b4168335decc38bfa0add90f517de426e547ebe36bd6eb840c05be98f",
      "bytes": 965
    },
    {
      "path": "deliverables/Moses_Centred_Chronological_Family.md",
      "sha256": "a6cb32355311f08c1084a7069e47dd4e79670b50e4c48107f08837a260f37ff6",
      "bytes": 2717
    }
  ],
  "source_bindings": [
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/project_sources/39-File_51a.Rounded_Scaffold_Mod5_Architecture.md",
      "sha256": "d8aa38afb2a2df8f3bb57937f5d3dea897c286c034a1bee7398938d30e7bd77c",
      "bytes": 196972
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/project_sources/38-File_18.Chronological_Data_Tables-20260919-141048-.md",
      "sha256": "68301ab760bfbe2e874aedc5c8d943ced7a6219d34bc2859332a70713f9630d5",
      "bytes": 221777
    }
  ],
  "prep_binding": {
    "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/prep/moses_centred_construction.json",
    "sha256": "e57828e95f298fb2e2800ee10633ea01205092b1157ab0c1a68b179d8df8990e",
    "bytes": 123419
  },
  "reviewed_script_bindings": [
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1232.py",
      "sha256": "b1fc751d634159caac7d6cb97654539788d62cbc6b554abecd9301fa5105f260",
      "bytes": 1625
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1233.py",
      "sha256": "fb6f1b468f7db186a47742374b1195ffc8559f80f80804e9cc12331e21683605",
      "bytes": 1344
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1234.py",
      "sha256": "e6caf44188a4219c8335ec5d7786ddf22acc7d4678d82c20812ebe539b716a0a",
      "bytes": 1639
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1235.py",
      "sha256": "87ac6ad8bf631fb9770823bf7452a7ccd9d7a446957424ccacb79788c51b05e2",
      "bytes": 1450
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1236.py",
      "sha256": "12d347b1c8b1da11c1d9d51c42a2a42800564f0e6b97418e0a9482262563600e",
      "bytes": 1288
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1237.py",
      "sha256": "a1f5773cd0babece21cf761ee74b6e0bd7ff26864c6e253f970062eb0da985d8",
      "bytes": 1124
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1238.py",
      "sha256": "58d6110d66d7a93608b9dbf6c90164bd58ad2ff464d7aa21493a085280c1e279",
      "bytes": 1206
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1239.py",
      "sha256": "c64cf79baadce4a3920b36d5b1661d68cc6b0a6e01935e64bd11e593b48cb251",
      "bytes": 1483
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1240.py",
      "sha256": "42d3916cbf953ed4c8e9baba4f100caf37540552f2ccbb3706890aca1f3354ed",
      "bytes": 1197
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1241.py",
      "sha256": "b8d788b1355596b5826bf7692790994f3ce649b178b28c43c9ea3010b174c2b7",
      "bytes": 1575
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1242.py",
      "sha256": "a1987c7cede7609c1d3d0efce01131dc5d40ea4f3a7a50091088c39ab2b894bc",
      "bytes": 1313
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1243.py",
      "sha256": "b742850ea6dc0cc4782925ddf26034106a2e1fb9cd6ecc6e81b4a76a8da0e198",
      "bytes": 1315
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1244.py",
      "sha256": "407d8ba50a9b4d3babc25dd88d1e5c45f85a23e53dea42db70f029f83d4e9ea1",
      "bytes": 1686
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1245.py",
      "sha256": "f3bd45d8812ad59fdc09dda267b630583c81694e44e351073bf3e21b02e471ee",
      "bytes": 1343
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1246.py",
      "sha256": "329e174975265821f3768bbd33c65041b31f6f8937e9a35740d4bde2e5a2e03c",
      "bytes": 1713
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1247.py",
      "sha256": "3cb7e450b2eec8187055644870ffd34b79f3248bc27f196e310d443e0202dd2b",
      "bytes": 1233
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1248.py",
      "sha256": "353788b9347053501bc942134288c4b158b97a63838c5c264d62d398d21ece75",
      "bytes": 1542
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1249.py",
      "sha256": "940c06c5749bf674281d22085c0fc5661791f1df7b26a467572a9bdcb45c181e",
      "bytes": 1437
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1250.py",
      "sha256": "159fdbd7bd12d61a35e8168dddeb3fd760f738ecd894de1c9a501d69c4cb83f5",
      "bytes": 1309
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1251.py",
      "sha256": "279151195126f54f4a2a16c28b68b759f5070359e4333d53a1dc1a0f8ac953fa",
      "bytes": 1612
    },
    {
      "path": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c1132_c1431/evidence/s1252.py",
      "sha256": "bcd7ba6e6b4dbc08740c9b2dd30a4537006ef9bb1b97dd65e6bab7392b15867e",
      "bytes": 3500
    }
  ]
}