INDEPENDENT C859 C870.json

{
  "reviewer": "nt_family",
  "scope": "C859–C870",
  "status": "PASS",
  "utc": "2026-09-28T02:47:37.900450+00:00",
  "method": "Independent recalculation from raw frozen source tables, not replay of root steps and not acceptance of normalized preparation outputs. Compared every generated field and all recorded artifact hashes.",
  "checks": {
    "frozen_source_File43": true,
    "frozen_source_File54": true,
    "frozen_source_File15": true,
    "frozen_source_File51a": true,
    "C860_full_78_rows_equal_literal_source": true,
    "C860_all_156_boundaries_regenerated": true,
    "C860_primary_and_extension": true,
    "C861_count_objects": true,
    "C862_full_22_field_equal_source": true,
    "C863_all_21_local_generators": true,
    "C863_all_22_suffix_recovery": true,
    "C864_literal_Cainan_130_control": true,
    "C864_23_restored_nodes": true,
    "C864_22_restored_edges": true,
    "C864_local_35_130_not_other_order": true,
    "C865_complete_22_residual_response": true,
    "C866_867_full_E_classification": true,
    "C866_867_full_P_classification": true,
    "C867_joint_source_only_0_69": true,
    "C868_all_six_translated_returns": true,
    "C868_all_79_boundaries_covariant": true,
    "C869_whole_grid_intersection": true,
    "C869_source_chiasm_partition": true,
    "C870_all_78_reflected_boundaries": true,
    "C870_source_marked_pair": true,
    "C870_no_fixed_index": true,
    "twelve_complete_sequential_records": true,
    "all_recorded_artifact_hashes": true
  },
  "facts": {
    "display_rows": 78,
    "display_boundaries_compared": 156,
    "native_comparison_nodes": 22,
    "native_local_edges": 21,
    "restored_comparison_nodes": 23,
    "restored_local_edges": 22,
    "residual_nodes": 22,
    "Key_domain_indices_per_operator": 77,
    "E_returns": 4,
    "P_returns": 2,
    "translated_returns": 6,
    "common_boundaries": 12,
    "reflected_boundaries": 78,
    "checks": 28,
    "literal_chiasm_rows_checked": [
      [
        "Luke head 5326 BC to BJ Creation 3856 BC",
        "1470",
        "30 × 49",
        "21 × 70"
      ],
      [
        "BJ Creation 3856 BC to Conquest 1406 BC",
        "2450",
        "50 × 49",
        "35 × 70"
      ],
      [
        "Conquest 1406 BC to AD 65",
        "1470",
        "30 × 49",
        "21 × 70"
      ],
      [
        "Luke head 5326 BC to BJ Creation 3856 BC",
        "1470",
        "30 × 49",
        "21 × 70"
      ],
      [
        "BJ Creation 3856 BC to Conquest 1406 BC",
        "2450",
        "50 × 49",
        "35 × 70"
      ],
      [
        "Conquest 1406 BC to AD 65",
        "1470",
        "30 × 49",
        "21 × 70"
      ]
    ]
  },
  "source_evidence": {
    "File43": {
      "snapshot": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c832_c931/evidence/sources/06-File_43.Genealogical_Bridge-2-.md",
      "sha256": "dde4eca7c1f64eaef93f1084cd6aef99776b38c7673c680e8ff8185c0fc5a987"
    },
    "File54": {
      "snapshot": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c832_c931/evidence/sources/07-File_54.Luke_70_Year_Genealogical_Lattice-5-.md",
      "sha256": "1ff1914fa180de2aba3e8bf1bb81a3478dc1f8b0153dc722019ff392c3c87899"
    },
    "File15": {
      "snapshot": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c832_c931/evidence/sources/04-File_15.Generational_Axiom-3-.md",
      "sha256": "548a6d186972f534c6934be415dbaf5f690004f41b31d8867f5da167b3086d78"
    },
    "File51a": {
      "snapshot": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c832_c931/evidence/sources/39-File_51a.Rounded_Scaffold_Mod5_Architecture.md",
      "sha256": "d8aa38afb2a2df8f3bb57937f5d3dea897c286c034a1bee7398938d30e7bd77c"
    },
    "File18": {
      "snapshot": "/workspace/scratch/1b40da62dcbd/c832_c931/evidence/sources/38-File_18.Chronological_Data_Tables-20260919-141048-.md",
      "sha256": "68301ab760bfbe2e874aedc5c8d943ced7a6219d34bc2859332a70713f9630d5",
      "Cainan_row_line": 637
    }
  },
  "journal_record_hashes": {
    "859": "8d2638cb1c9bef42d2b30bc6aef5d543dd968a9e47f3e83126bc7ad52611dbe8",
    "860": "0464cc06d80c7c8782c6c555be8525ee0f81c0c6c204383a28f9422ae19dfaaf",
    "861": "cd86c18ce8b1f56952ffb129af7c6018b61fe9996566fd6e6c0c70ed75ee005c",
    "862": "a02db01cc47b311258ec1c7766d2aaaefeba9e9472cba852993ed45c46464cd9",
    "863": "37cec6797f0ceb696df7a2ddd1f8c657114f23833566351a15f0657e4ddc19ca",
    "864": "58d487895dbd08301aa61e539d71286618c82441251659f4d478eae2f0c866a2",
    "865": "c79c7f8c239c903fe383e3ca39d6c8ea42998b0a3dadd441b6224fce694e1df2",
    "866": "7a7af985e43def3235d6fa05b9eb770002797be530012a5eb1ba9c126ab729df",
    "867": "7a8edf503220bac4fa6cc2071be672264bd6651a5a7455709612072580b155c4",
    "868": "9a5ee3519b97a41fa59f8de443ed94a569821a97a15e65f6031c8db5acc5378d",
    "869": "efff108af7686541b55686e404c8464619509f11f66b6e1b153a64d1cc9470be",
    "870": "c5ecb28c7d72d1ad6512bb04a55589e9abdb6197051c16431c18164ba5199f4c"
  },
  "findings": {
    "numerical_corrections_required": [],
    "material_overclaims": [],
    "nonblocking_notes": [
      "C869 check literal_field compares against a derived preparation field; it is not an independent literal source table. This review instead independently computes the full grid intersection and checks the source chiasm partition.",
      "C868 generated Jesus-label36BC row is the declared display rail; it must not be called a revised Nativity date.",
      "C864 generated restored MT nodes retain strict File51a no-Shem+2 state; MT Cainan2551 is source-controlled and the local35|130 order is correct."
    ]
  }
}