{
"status": "PASS with small reader revisions; no blocking or arithmetic findings",
"scope": "Independent presentation and relationship review of the frozen proposed reader architecture, six-lane map, caption and relationship table; this does not add research actions or a claim of historical/statistical independence. Existing root files were not changed.",
"source_basis": "Local frozen supplied sources and completed models only. No external sources, quarantined primers, second reversal or new endpoint search.",
"input_hashes": [
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/final_common_architecture_draft.md",
"sha256": "b723f55eec6eddaa01ecb5ca0c20351726a859ae124bf4ba3e7eddceb707cde1"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/common_representation_architecture.md",
"sha256": "22832f5fd8764345f17e216fcbb08e4c2935c32692254790dc24e60dc9d8a71f"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/Family_Map_Proposal.svg",
"sha256": "74f3d1c7e77db58e2004ddc44e1d78a85e807647ffd2079e8e8c77e23c56ec09"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/Family_Map_Proposal.png",
"sha256": "98ad2eab28511b704c4dff5577575f5e9b296ec9802095f07d6ae86a4241e429"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/Family_Map_Caption.md",
"sha256": "394408cb5e84acfc21b1dcb5a94612c0ab1bb0e51ec19d6ae4851c8cec091592"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/Family_Map_Relationships.md",
"sha256": "31255538a00dcd23a2a69bc5c2dba9ff0ddaa9825daf0c3ecca0cee4d9d1f580"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/Family_Map_Design.json",
"sha256": "7ea5f355e385e9d94341cdd5ec41f5eac638d6098e88ae7fa16f5f72555ee064"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/Family_Map_Source_Bindings.json",
"sha256": "97abad1238b2997406de26d58a793b0607140f3b75ea02bfb48e837ec43f1bf0"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/claim_source_status_C1315.md",
"sha256": "830c71a36b95bbbc533dae6040bd85971baa198ec343a4b407554e9ae80344a4"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/prep/claim_source_status_C1315.json",
"sha256": "2da670a15fd4c592a193c95a6d7e780da14d3a922bbe43b226b3032a98235263"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/model/Regular_kernel_presentation_bridge.json",
"sha256": "ed859ecdaf3f3e37b7d587963ad7039fa3765ee4d36fbf2703b91bd30bb51041"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/sources/Strategy.md",
"sha256": "9c9aa357f5483b3af1dbb5f0025ee514fa28160576a037be03037aa49bf01476"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/sources/38-File_18.Chronological_Data_Tables-20260919-141048-.md",
"sha256": "68301ab760bfbe2e874aedc5c8d943ced7a6219d34bc2859332a70713f9630d5"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/sources/39-File_51a.Rounded_Scaffold_Mod5_Architecture.md",
"sha256": "d8aa38afb2a2df8f3bb57937f5d3dea897c286c034a1bee7398938d30e7bd77c"
},
{
"path": "c1132_c1431/evidence/sources/File52c_latest.md",
"sha256": "a5ea84562101158b60d0cf296765d6eff38e7a2abda4e74ad1b353dfd13b9530"
}
],
"binding_validation": {
"count": 40,
"status": "PASS"
},
"checks": [
{
"check": "All map source/model/artifact bindings retain their frozen hash and byte length",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 40,
"expected": 40
},
{
"check": "Six source-construction lanes",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 6,
"expected": 6
},
{
"check": "Four nodes in every lane",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
4,
4,
4,
4,
4,
4
],
"expected": [
4,
4,
4,
4,
4,
4
]
},
{
"check": "SVG dimensions",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
"1600",
"1630"
],
"expected": [
"1600",
"1630"
]
},
{
"check": "Regular native insertion",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
1380
],
"expected": [
1380
]
},
{
"check": "Cumulative native insertion",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
890
],
"expected": [
890
]
},
{
"check": "All nineteen changes accumulate to the twenty-node Regular field",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
1250,
1150,
1050,
950,
850,
750,
750,
650,
650,
650,
650,
650,
550,
450,
350,
250,
150,
50,
0,
0
],
"expected": [
1250,
1150,
1050,
950,
850,
750,
750,
650,
650,
650,
650,
650,
550,
450,
350,
250,
150,
50,
0,
0
]
},
{
"check": "Creation-to-Noah field difference",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 600,
"expected": 600
},
{
"check": "Five full Moses block sums",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
130,
490,
1030,
130,
800
],
"expected": [
130,
490,
1030,
130,
800
]
},
{
"check": "Rounded Moses path total",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 2580,
"expected": 2580
},
{
"check": "Rounded Creation at held Moses1526",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 4106,
"expected": 4106
},
{
"check": "All three original word differences",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
[
1400,
1050,
1650
],
[
1400,
1650,
1050
],
[
1400,
1050,
600,
1050
]
],
"expected": [
[
1400,
1050,
1650
],
[
1400,
1650,
1050
],
[
1400,
1050,
600,
1050
]
]
},
{
"check": "All three original word matches",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
[
1400,
1050,
1650
],
[
1400,
1650,
1050
],
[
1400,
1050,
600,
1050
]
],
"expected": [
[
1400,
1050,
1650
],
[
1400,
1650,
1050
],
[
1400,
1050,
600,
1050
]
]
},
{
"check": "Established inverse completion",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": "16000",
"expected": "16000"
},
{
"check": "Three SP cap losses",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 488,
"expected": 488
},
{
"check": "SP whole Regular change",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 300,
"expected": 300
},
{
"check": "SP whole Cumulative change",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": -608,
"expected": -608
},
{
"check": "Both rectangle gains",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
"40",
"40"
],
"expected": [
"40",
"40"
]
},
{
"check": "Rectangle difference retained",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
9200,
9200
],
"expected": [
9200,
9200
]
},
{
"check": "Full Covenant clutch",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 14,
"expected": 14
},
{
"check": "Seven distinct life contributions in the ten-node equal-birth suffix",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 7,
"expected": 7
},
{
"check": "Source lifespan difference under NT birth comparison",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": 547,
"expected": 547
},
{
"check": "Source placement choices",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
0,
60,
130,
190,
215,
275,
345,
405
],
"expected": [
0,
60,
130,
190,
215,
275,
345,
405
]
},
{
"check": "Both coefficient-five source calibrations",
"status": "PASS",
"actual": [
1250,
650
],
"expected": [
1250,
650
]
}
],
"visual_review": {
"status": "PASS",
"method": "Viewed full PNG at its native aspect ratio and inspected SVG text/structure",
"findings": "No clipped labels, crossed arrows or illegible small citations observed. Four-node lanes remain readable; prose caption provides the units and qualifications not repeated in every box."
},
"findings": [
{
"id": "kernel_bridge",
"severity": "minor_reader_revision",
"location": "final_common_architecture_draft.md, after ordered accumulation paragraph",
"finding": "The prose describes the row-change staircase but leaves the other newly explained Regular mechanism implicit. The map relationship table now contains it.",
"proposed_text": "The same sources also supply three finite placement choices: Terah 60, Cainan 130 and Sojourn 215, whose eight combinations span 405 years. This placement family and the 1250/650 row-change staircase meet through the source calibration C=1.3u and T=0.6u at u=100; they arise from different source operations.",
"support": "Strategy §4.1; File18 §§1.6,2–4; File07 §2.11.1a; C1253–1264; model/Regular_kernel_presentation_bridge.json"
},
{
"id": "plural_source_title",
"severity": "optional_wording",
"location": "draft title and map footer",
"finding": "The argument uses a common kind of labelled structure across genealogies and count objects, rather than one literal source dataset for every lane.",
"proposed_text": "Shared source structures, different chronological measurements",
"support": "Strategy whole-family objective; map caption explicitly preserves distinct objects."
},
{
"id": "residual_register",
"severity": "minor_reader_revision",
"location": "draft rounding paragraph; map lane2 first box",
"finding": "Retaining exact residuals is the reconstruction register used here. It should not sound like a claim that the source Rounded chronology itself explicitly stores every residual.",
"proposed_text": "Our reconstruction retains both the nearest-five value of each row and its exact residual.",
"support": "File51a §§3.1,3.4,16; C1190–1222, C1277–1278, C1297–1298."
},
{
"id": "strict_actual_partition",
"severity": "minor_reader_revision",
"location": "draft sentence: The exact partition is 129 and 801",
"finding": "Name the strict Actual source state when presenting 129|801, so the reader does not combine it with the standard 4114 comparison used elsewhere.",
"proposed_text": "In the strict Actual state used for this path, the corresponding partition is 129 and 801.",
"support": "File51a §3.1; C1232–1252; strict path 2586/4112 versus Rounded2580/4106."
},
{
"id": "caption_anchor_scope",
"severity": "minor_reader_revision",
"location": "Family_Map_Caption.md, opening paragraph",
"finding": "The opening briefly says the Rounded Moses path supplies the original words; the next paragraph correctly adds the File52c source event nodes. State this joint input immediately.",
"proposed_text": "The Rounded Moses path joins File52c’s supplied event nodes to recover the three original Regular component words.",
"support": "Latest File52c §§2.1,3.3–3.4; C1273–1276; model/Moses_inverse_source_word_match.json."
}
],
"claim_status_table": {
"markdown": "prep/claim_source_status_C1315.md",
"json": "prep/claim_source_status_C1315.json",
"status": "Ready for selective use; eight compact reader rows with fuller source/role records in JSON."
},
"three_strongest_explanatory_contributions": [
"A complete mechanism connects SP birth intervals to the nine capacities and selected lives. Its located losses then explain the Cumulative field and feed the established rectangle with placement and openings still supplied.",
"The full Rounded Moses reconstruction supplies Creation and Noah to the original File52c words, with separately supplied event nodes. This connects genealogical rows to the inherited inverse family through an explicit path rather than equal endpoints alone.",
"The two-coordinate row grammar separates birth changes from lifespan changes across whole MT/SP/LXX families. The Regular kernel and NT shared-birth suffix show why source measures can agree in one register and differ in another."
],
"independence_guard": "Shared rows, selected baselines, anchors and source calibrations are shared premises. Agreement of their calculated descendants is explanatory reconstruction, not extra independent testimony. The current architecture, table and map preserve this distinction."
}
Evidence
reader architecture review C1315.json
Linked sources and evidence
Edition and provenance
reader_architecture_review_C1315.json
SHA-256 b0836d6df5bba7368ecbf8395667fb55ddc980c527cc065b4d62e19d8780f0f7
C480–C1634/Research_Cycles/C1132_C1431_Recovered/prep/reader_architecture_review_C1315.json