# C530 — Reconcile independent review

## Question

Do the independent reviews change the arithmetic or the scope of the combined explanation?

## Inputs

```json
{
  "reviewed_range": "C482–C521",
  "reviewed_entries": 40,
  "supplied_assertions_replayed_by_reviewers": 103,
  "review_notes": [
    "INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_C482_C501.md",
    "INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_C502_C511.md",
    "INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_C512_C521.md"
  ]
}
```

## Sources

```json
[
  "three independent review notes in evidence/"
]
```

## Opened utc

2026-09-27T22:55:54.457273+00:00

## Results

```json
{
  "numerical_corrections_required": 0,
  "synthesis_qualifications": [
    "LXX means native Cainan ON in the full430 comparison frame; its derived rounded Noah/Flood path is a transfer test, not a separately tabulated series.",
    "Decimal gain formulas assume nonzero outer digits: three-digit core a,c=1..9,b=0..9; two-digit core a,b=1..9.",
    "MT Jared/Noah/Flood all have integral E/J outputs; only Noah admits integral P as well.",
    "Rounded reflection’s same-label rule here uses nonzero comparison coordinates; it creates no civil year zero.",
    "Cainan+330 bridge applies to matched upstream projections with anchors held; the mixed midpoint is an additional placement constraint, not an Actual-mode date.",
    "Temple junction needs E(14030+10580)=26750 and1616−696=(E−1)10580=920; identifying forward1526 as reflected Moses additionally uses1526−1446=(E−1)920=80.",
    "Anchor-switch1280 is directly controlled by File52c §3.7.3; SP rectangle head/frame connection is now explicit in C523."
  ],
  "review_scope": "bounded independent arithmetic, state and dependency review; no historical probability or whole-repository recertification"
}
```

## Finding

The three reviews require no numerical correction. Their wording and dependency clarifications are adopted in the final draft. The research record retains failures and uninstantiated source paths alongside successful reconstructions.

## Reassessment

Write the integrated explanation and updated checkpoint; close the50-step sequence with its next bounded test.

## Checks

```json
{
  "notes_present": true,
  "assertions": true
}
```

## Closed utc

2026-09-27T22:55:54.457630+00:00

## Record provenance

Exact record hash: `683c7e362bb46b6cb132b423c01ef1c6e2eb9642a5eb981cdf6d01d32588fc0d`

Source journal: `Research_Cycles/C0482_C0531/journal.json`