# Independent review of C652–C664

**PASS for arithmetic, source bindings, and operation scope.** No numerical correction or journal rewrite is required. Two phase-display clarifications are recommended for the synthesis.

## Method

Read the primary preparation memo, File70 §§4.3–4.5,5.1–5.8,9.1A and the relevant primary source roles, then inspected all13 current scripts and completed records. Replayed only C652–C664 with in-memory begin/finish/artifact replacements and write-blocking audit guards. All35 recorded checks and complete metadata/results matched. Existing journal records were unchanged. The replay report is `REVIEW_C652_C664_REPLAY.json`.

Independently recomputed both Jacob reflections, the30/40 seam, local Noah/Shem translations, the70-indexed body, the175-unit macro spine, exact half-year transfers, corresponding12075 triples, and the147/490 partition. No earlier-cycle script or archive was replayed.

## Findings

| Step | Review |
|---|---|
|C652|Reflection x↦3718−x reverses the entire five-node path about1859.1789 is correctly retained as a secondary traditional Judah role;1782 is the separately controlled Levi endpoint.|
|C653|The biographical path70/7/70 has midpoint1932.5 and is a different symmetric object from the death-centered path. Shared1936/1929/1859 labels do not make the centers identical.|
|C654|The common1899 seam requires1929−1859=30+40. The outer140 is consequently doubled70. The29-day diagnostic1900 correctly exposes the schematic30-day premise.|
|C655|Birth1915 and ages17/30/37/44 generate the entire1898/1885/1878/1871 path. Creation(13,1) and Joseph(13,14) are not uniform scalar copies.|
|C656|All alternative-date rows have60/70/60 gaps. Noah G2 is G1+2; the displayed Shem G1 comparison is Noah G1−150. Local Noah/Shem scope is preserved.|
|C657|190 of variant spread plus210 to Joseph1898 gives400. The record properly distinguishes alternative Noah death coordinates from successive events and from the separate Affliction400.|
|C658|x(k)=5436−70k generates the stated indices0/49/50/69/70 and retains the regular/cumulative/captivity/restoration role distinctions. The three cuts are dependent partitions of one4900 body.|
|C659|The full matrix1400/1470/1330/1400 is generated by two matching70-wide rails. The duplicate1400 is properly treated as dependent.|
|C660|Exodus1446 is index57 and yields the50/7/13 partition. Its event-role selection remains an independent source premise.|
|C661|The49/20/8 coefficients in175 units reconstruct14011/5436/1936/536; total13475=77×175=275×49 is exact.|
|C662|With outer5436/536 fixed, shifting only1936 to1936.5 changes the arms3500/1400 to3499.5/1400.5 and preserves4900. This is a correct one-junction phase diagnostic.|
|C663|All three source pairs differ by12075, and the complete cross-matrix is correct. P sends69×175 to70×175=12250.13997 remains a source lower companion.|
|C664|The whole-year path2083/1936/1446 gives147+490=637, or3+10 Jubilees. The corporate household boundary does not identify individual sons or ordinary birth dates.|

## Phase clarifications for the synthesis

**C662 holds the outer nodes fixed.** Its result should be described as a one-junction phase perturbation, not as the complete phase-resolved reconstruction of every node on the macro spine. The input record already makes the fixed outer pair explicit; repeat that qualification when extracting the finding into prose or a diagram.

**C664 uses whole-year2083 as well as whole-year1936.** The source's exact2083.5→1936.5 pair preserves Jacob's147. From1936.5 to an unchanged1446 the lower arm is490.5, so the total is637.5; the corresponding exact1446.5 comparison restores490 and637. The completed record's integer arithmetic is correct, but the diagram should label the entire2083/1936/1446 path as its whole-year display rather than marking only the central node.

## Source-role cautions to retain

- The Jacob reflection uses a controlled Levi endpoint and a weaker traditional Judah inner label. Five matching coordinates do not imply five equal evidentiary weights.
- The70+7 mourning values are two numbered ritual stations. The source does not assert77 uninterrupted elapsed days because the journey is unnumbered. The year/day comparison is schematic correspondence, not physical unit identity.
- The30/40 seam remains secondary and conditional on a schematic30-day month and the source's40-within70 mourning interpretation.1899 remains generated, distinct from Joseph1898.
- The Noah rows are variant positions. Their common shape and local+2 comparison do not authorize gear transport to Creation, Terah, or later patriarchs.
- The70-indexed cumulative body includes regular and cumulative source nodes. A common lattice index does not turn those node classes into one ordinary historical sequence.

The strongest common explanation is a small set of finite objects—two reflections, local translated variant rows, an indexed4900 body, and a175-unit cumulative spine—with source roles and phase choices retained. This is more informative than treating each equal span as an independent alignment.